Talking Points: March 2010

Of course no review will ever be absolutely comprehensive, but hopefully this will give a taster of the topics and trends interesting local bloggers in the past four weeks.

Here's Reading List's archive of local blog news for March 2010.

-

There was a major national story breaking on our doorsteps when news emerged of a Cookham B&B owner who turned away a gay couple on religious grounds.

Unwelcome Guests

The story encapsulated the potential legal conflicts arising from the new Equality Bill passing through parliament as the right to be free from discrimination on grounds of sexual orientation or religious conscience were shown to be in competition, leaving a minefield of issues to be negotiated as incoherencies in the bill began to be exposed.

It also brought together a range of different themes highlighting a tangible consequence of what happens when political ideas don't account for people.


Religious issues were one strong theme as conscience and conscientiousness were on our minds, maybe relating to the build-up towards Easter festivities.

Unwelcome Guests; De-sacre-ated; The Bishop's Progress

As well as the question of where to draw the boundaries between public and private rights (as highlighted by the decision of the guesthouse owner to raise objections to particular guests), the matter of fulfilling public responsibilities was raised as Reading's Lead Councillor for Education was forcibly removed from a key advisory committee on religious affairs for his failure to attend any meetings.

Meanwhile Reading's current Bishop of Reading was promoted for his success in assuming new roles as a community leader on moral issues facing society, showing that private beliefs can be a powerful motivating force influencing the public debate.


Maidenhead
was at the crossroads of a selection of stories.

Unwelcome Guests; Conservatives Divided On Support For Equality; Maidenhead Tories In Plot Turmoil

The usually tranquil idyll on the south bank of the Thames brought into focus a series of problems arising from an insular mentality. The petty prejudices that can exist when allowed to fester in isolation were matched at official level by their elected representatives.

Maidenhead MP Theresa May attempted to gloss over the divisions the idealistic representatives and ideological activists in her party, while internal competition between those factions at the borough level of Maidenhead Conservatives showed how groups can be torn apart from within as they approach their day of reckoning and each side vie for control.


Potholes were once again high up on the agenda.

Potholes Pile Up; Blitz On Poltholes

The humble pothole is turning into a powerful metaphor for the economic and regulatory problems facing the country in the aftermath of the credit crunch.

Inadequate road maintenance budgets across the county have been exposed by the harsh winter as an area where political parties have used their control of budgets to cut corners and costs on basic necessities in order to fund more politically desirable initiatives.

But attempts to convince the public that roads are being brought back up to standard have been scorned. Opposition parties argued the quick fixes ignored the systemic problems of cynically politicised budgets used for electoral purposes - this makes the problems intractable and likely to be recurrent.


Additional council spending
was also announced in a number of areas.

Blitz On Poltholes; Political Fight Over Play Areas; It's Tree Time!

Councils across Berkshire responded to criticism of their maintenance of roads by finding significant sums of money to placate commuters, while in Reading families and householders saw their interests brought to the front of politicians minds - there's nothing like an imminent election to spur announcements of action!


City status issues
continue to be covered as interest in the matter reached into the highest office and across the globe.

Flattering To Deceive; More City Views

On the one hand Labour leader Gordon Brown intervened in an attempt to influence the outcome of the Royal Charter competition by stating Reading 'deserved' to be a city, while on the other California-based expat blogger Claire Auchterlonie explained why the town is easily (and regularly) overlooked by the Queen, despite - or perhaps because - of the proximity of her major residence at Windsor Castle.


But overall the biggest trend of the month was a general focus on statistical measures of performance - perhaps this reflected increased attention paid to figures as the end of the financial year approached...

Top Of The Berkshire Blogs; Recommended Reading List #52; The Casework Competition; Axis Of Authoritarianism; J.O.B.S.; Blitz On Potholes; Crime Confusion Stirs Fresh Controversy

In addition to Reading List's regular chart of the most influential local blogs, statistical compilations into league tables were published and analysed in the areas of NHS trust performance, local councillor diligence, MP voting records on civil liberties, public employment levels, road maintenance performance and crime clear-up performance.

When tailored correctly to its subject information becomes a powerful tool for social change and improvement - then it's only a matter of the political will to apply the lessons provided by the information... though more often than not ruling politicians it seem to wish to hide from the embarrassment of what it says about what they've achieved!

-

Life is never dull in Reading, but how any of these talking points play out is something we'll just have to wait and watch... or contribute to ourselves.

We can all make a difference to the lives we live by discussing the choices we face and giving our opinion, so if you want to participate in the online debate contact Oranjepan and Reading List will monitor your local blog too - so why not have your say and get blogging!

-

Previous month's Talking Points

Talking Points: February 2010

Of course no review will ever be absolutely comprehensive, but hopefully this will give a taster of the topics and trends interesting local bloggers in the past four weeks.

Here's Reading List's archive of local blog news for February 2010.

-

The big issue was clearly the annual budget debate.

R-Words; Proposed Council Tax Rates Across Berkshire; The Berkshire Council Debate: Views And Perspectives; Council Tax Debate Leaves Conservatives Red-Faced; An Overview Of Democracy In Action

There were a range of proposals to resolve the opposing financial and social pressures brought up by the current economic conditions.

Each borough authority across the county has different demographic and administrative pressures and found separate solutions, but it is still possible to discern some trends.

Conservative rhetoric has been for cuts to taxation and spending as a way to boost the economy, however this has been challenged in different regards.

Council services appear to offer lower value for money where tories are in power in Wokingham and Bracknell as the tax rises are offset by higher service cuts, a state of affairs which has arisen due to bad financial planning and lower scrutiny of accounts. This future also faces Windsor and Maidenhead as Conservative plans to slash budgets were criticised for following a flawed business model, while in Reading the Conservative party refused to submit an alternative motion on the budget for fear of exposing this prior to local elections where they hope to take power.

Labour continues to be in favour of above-inflation rises in spending on public services, while LibDems have been criticised for varying their position according to circumstances.


General election campaigning stepped up a gear.

Tories Face Questions Over Funding; Conservatives Criticised For Hyping Fear Of Crime; Budget Debate Leaves Conservatives Red-Faced

Right-wingers got egg on their faces as Conservatives faced a barrage of attacks on all fronts. They appear to have abdicated any claim to their traditional 'bread and butter' policies of morality and standards in public life, law and order and financial competence.

And both Conservatives and Labour were criticised for having insufficient policy proposals by the professional body of the IT industry.

Meanwhile left-wingers have been arguing over their claims to represent an accurate view of reality as Green and Labour candidates enjoyed a robust exchange of views.


The issue of equality in society was drawn into focus.

The Pink Party; Equal Opportunists

Conservatives attempted to defend themselves against accusations that their proposals wouldn't do as much as other parties to stamp out homophobic bullying in society, accusing other parties of politicising the issue.

Retiring Labour MP Martin Salter was embarrassed by the groundswell of public reaction against his contribution to the equality debate when he chose to verbally abuse Pope Benedict XVI, calling him "a bloke in a dress."


Issues of new media were under the spotlight.

Fit To Print; The IT Crowd

32 regional newspaper titles - including Reading Post - were sold by parent company GMG in a move which poses the economic challenge represented by freedom of information to big corporations. GMG has been an ardent defender of the free online content model, but big losses created by online expansion has forced the company to rationalise their position.

And representatives of the IT community came together to lobby on behalf of the public, urging political parties to make a stronger committment to enabling greater access to the economic potential of information technology.


The debate over Reading's bid for city status rumbles on.

City Splits; RRL #49

While an unlikely grand coalition has broken out between Labour and Conservative parties in favour of the bid the public appears completely split down the middle on the question. LibDems surpised some onlookers by failing to join in the political consensus by asking some detailed questions on the value it represents.

That's not to say anyone is doing down Reading town. Far from it in fact, as one local poster comments, Reading is already "a real hub of fantastic events," which begs the question whether any tangible advantages would come from a change in status, or indeed if it would lead to any at all.


And on a positive note in campaign news campaigners celebrated success with the apparent conclusion of two local campaigns.

Jolly Days; United Opposition Defeats Developers

It appears the efforts to ensure the future of communities will be designed to suit the wishes of the people in those communities rather than those of outside forces gained a boost this month as the high-profile campaign to find new permanent owners for the Jolly Anglers pub on Kennetside was successful. The Jolly Anglers pub opened its' doors again on 1st March.

And residents declared themselves satisfied by the rejection of contentious plans to build 750 houses on a prime piece of green-belt land between Reading and Theale.


But just as two sets of campaigns reach the finishing line, another continues on and a fourth starts up.

Mass Demo Against Weapons Of Mass Destruction; Barriers To Safety

Anti-nuclear protesters were out in force as a major decision was taken to build a nuclear waste store and new weapons facilities at Aldermaston, and a fatal road traffic accident lead to concerns about traffic safety on a local dual-carriageway.

Interestingly each of those four campaigns highlighted the contradiction not just between party political interests, but between the differing interests of local and national politicians.


Volunteers Spring To Action

For some it showed how the gap can be exploited for electoral gain, but for others it offered an indication that the solution to problems can be found not by leaving these matters to others, but by getting more involved in the community.

-

Life is never dull in Reading, but how any of these talking points play out is something we'll just have to wait and watch... or contribute to ourselves.

We can all make a difference to the lives we live by discussing the choices we face and giving our opinion, so if you want to participate in the online debate contact Oranjepan and Reading List will monitor your local blog too - so why not have your say and get blogging!

-

Previous month's Talking Points

Talking Points: January 2010

As a new feature for the new year I've decided it's worth having a look back at the month gone by to pick up any trends in what local bloggers have been most interested in.

Of course no review will ever be comprehensive, but hopefully this will give a taster.

Here's Reading List's archive of local blog news for January 2010.

-

Bookending the month were two big debates.

- The first of these was the ongoing attention paid to the way authorities responded to the winter weather crisis.

More Weather On The Agenda; Round-Up: Snow - The Sequel; Winter Warmer; Beneath The Surface; The Snow Summit

After parts of Berkshire descended into temporary chaos when a blizzard hit giving the country the first white Christmas in years bloggers were well primed for another bout.

Although the second wave was accompanied by less outspoken criticism it did throw up a variety of responses which began to look into the causes and effects of public policy on the physical and ambient environment.

Dealing with the immediate problems of heavy snow and ice was the big concern for many, but this quickly turned into a debate about climate change and how and whether to pay for the damage it causes. Prevention is better than a cure, but do we have to learn to live with the situation which faces us?


- At the other end of the month the proposal for Reading to bid for city status came up for discussion.

Is Reading A City?
; Reading's City Bid Approved

The civic movement saw a big split between those who feel this is a banner moment to help improve the local economy by raising the standing of the community and those who feel it is more about appearances than real improvements.

Underlying the debate are questions about local government economics and accountability. Primary among these is the desire to reshape the boundaries of the unitary authority in line with the actual area of the urban unit.

The most recent boundary changes left Woodley, Earley, Calcot and some parts of Tilehurst outside Reading borough, and since there is a demographic split between urban and suburban residents on either side about where they want decisions to be taken this is naturally controversial.


- In between the two, the upcoming General Election came into focus as party manifestos started to be set out by candidates.

Cameron Indirectly; Splash To Backlash

Conservative Party leader David Cameron visited the town (at the second attempt) to talk about his plans.

Initially it was to launch his pledge to protect the NHS from the swinging cuts to public spending he envisages and answer specific questions from the public, but in the event invitations were given to a limited selection of activists and media at short notice to recognise volunteer groups and the emphasis he will place on supporting the third sector as a means out of budget troubles.

Car Park Spats; Countdown To The Budget; Labour Crumbles In Face of 'Call In'

This was followed by the incumbent Labour administration's laying out it's proposals.

It became apparent that Labour's strategy to minimise painful cuts to the public budget was to increase revenues from peripheral charges, such as on parking. So when it became clear that the level of increases were excessive opposition strengthened and the proposals were scaled back. This ties the hands of budget setters and pressure will be on to keep headline council tax rises down in this election year.

Making Minds Up In Reading West; Local LibDems Recognised For Online Activism; Opening Doors To New And Empty Homes

Meanwhile LibDems were also fully engaged as Redlands representative Cllr Daisy Benson was selected as the PPC in Reading West.

This came as little surprise considering the successes she has had using social media to reach out to members of the public and on changing local housing policy as chair of one of Reading's main scrutiny committees. She is clearly a rising star among local politicians nationwide and very much at the heart of the LibDem party, as was shown when party leader Nick Clegg announced his ideas on housing.

SADs, Dams And 'Lies' In Green-field Dispute; A Comedy Manifesto

Green Party activists were also to be seen looking for a way to make their presence felt in the political arena.

Rob White, who hopes to get elected as the first Green councillor in Reading, got involved in a dispute over protecting a local playing field. He also got to meet celebrity supporter Mark Thomas when he gave a comedy show in the town.


-

Life is never dull in Reading, but how any of these talking points play out is something we'll just have to wait and watch... or contribute to ourselves!

We can all make a difference to the lives we live by discussing the choices we face and giving our opinion, so if you want to participate in the online debate contact Oranjepan and Reading List will monitor your local blog too - get blogging!